Cancer is a major healthcare burden across the world and impacts not only the people diagnosed with various cancers but also their families, carers, and healthcare systems. With advances in the diagnosis and treatment, more people are diagnosed early and receive treatments for a disease where few treatments options were previously available. As a result, the survival of patients with cancer has steadily improved and, in most cases, patients who are not cured may receive multiple lines of treatment, often with financial consequences for the patients, insurers and healthcare systems. Although many books exist that address economic evaluation, Economic Evaluation of Cancer Drugs using Clinical Trial and Real World Data is the first unified text that specifically addresses the economic evaluation of cancer drugs.
The authors discuss how to perform cost-effectiveness analyses while emphasising the strategic importance of designing cost-effectiveness into cancer trials and building robust economic evaluation models that have a higher chance of reimbursement if truly cost-effective. They cover the use of real-world data using cancer registries and discuss how such data can support or complement clinical trials with limited follow up. Lessons learned from failed reimbursement attempts, factors predictive of successful reimbursement and the different payer requirements across major countries including US, Australia, Canada, UK, Germany, France and Italy are also discussed. The book includes many detailed practical examples, case studies and thought-provoking exercises for use in classroom and seminar discussions.
Iftekhar Khan is a medical statistician and health economist and a lead statistician at Oxford Unviersity's Center for Statistics in Medicine. Professor Khan is also a Senior Research Fellow in Health Economics at University of Warwick and is a Senior Statistical Assessor within the Licensing Division of the UK Medicine and Health Regulation Agency.
Ralph Crott is a former professor in Pharmacoeconomics at the University of Montreal in Quebec, Canada and former head of the EORTC Health Economics Unit and former senior health economist at the Belgian HTA organization.
Zahid Bashir has over twelve years experience working in the pharmaceutical industry in medical affairs and oncology drug development where he is involved in the design and execution of oncology clinical trials and development of reimbursement dossiers for HTA submission. "This book is highly recommended for readers searching for an introductory text to the world of health economic analysis. The authors provide timely examples from both clinical trials in oncology and subsequent real-world application, discussing implications of findings and how they could potentially be applied to make future trials and real-world applications more efficient. ~Nuru Noor, ISCB News
Economic Evaluation of Cancer Drugs: Using Clinical Trial and Real-World Data
1. Introduction to Cancer
Cancer
Epidemiology of Cancer
Prognostic factors associated with cancer outcomes
Economic Burden of Cancer
Treatments for Cancer
Important Economic Concepts for Cost-Effectiveness of Cancer interventions
Health Economic Evaluation and Cancer Drug Development in Practice
Efficacy versus Effectiveness
Real World Data
Economic versus Clinical Hypotheses
Exercises
2. Introduction
Important Common, Surrogate and Novel Cancer Endpoints
Overall Survival
Surrogate Endpoints
HTAs with Surrogate Endpoints
Emerging Tumour-Centred Endpoints
Demonstrating Value from other cancer endpoints
Exercises
3. Health Related Quality of Life for Cost-effectiveness
Health Related Quality of Life (HRQoL) in cancer patients
Measuring HRQoL for Economic Evaluation
Constructing Utilities
Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs)
Economic Evaluation in the Absence of Utility Data: Mapping and Utility Studies
Sensitivity and Responsiveness of EQ-D versus QLQ-C HRQoL for detecting improvement in cancer patients
Measuring Post-Progression Utility: Some Approaches
Plausible Post-Progression Utility Behaviour
Non-Linear Models
HRQoL issues in Health Technology Appraisals of Cancer Drugs
Exercises
4. Introductory Statistical Methods for Economic Evaluation in Cancer
Introduction
Uncertainty and variability
Distributions: Cost, Utility and Survival Data
Important measures used in cancer trials
Simulation: Bootstrapping and Monte-Carlo Simulation
Analysing Data from cancer Trials
Semi-Parametric Methods - The Cox PH model
Parametric Methods: Modelling Survival Data for Extrapolation
Advanced Modelling Techniques for Survival Data
Issues in fitting models
Handling Crossover, Treatment Switching and Subsequent anti-cancer therapy
Data Synthesis and Network Meta Analyses
Mixed Treatment Comparisons
Assumptions for carrying out MTCs
Exercises
5. Collecting and Analysis of Costs from Cancer Studies
Types of costs typical of cancer trials
Perspective of analysis and costs collection
Collecting Health Resource use across the treatment pathway
Costing methods: micro versus macro approach
Charges
Distribution of Costs
Handling Censored and Missing Costs
Strategies for avoiding missing resource data
Strategies for analysing cost data when data are missing or censored
Handling Future Costs
Case Report Forms and Health Resource Use
Statistical Analyses of Costs
Exercises
6. Designing Cost-effectiveness into Cancer Trials
Introduction and Reasons for Collecting Economic Data in a Clinical Trial
Clinical Trial Designs for Cancer Studies
Planning a Health Economic Evaluation in a Clinical Trial
Important considerations when designing a cancer study for economic evaluation
Integrating Economic Evaluation in a Clinical Trial: Considerations
Figure : Clustered data within each centre
Case study of Economic Evaluation of cancer trials
Exercises
7. Models for Economic Evaluation of Cancer
Types of Health Economic Models
Decision Tree Models
Markov Models
Continuous time Markov Models
The partitioned survival model
Developing an economic model using patient level data using a partitioned survival model approach
Case Study of an economic model using patient level data: a partitioned survival model
Summary of Cost-Effectiveness Models for Cancer used in HTA submissions
Exercises
8. Real World Data in Cost-Effectiveness studies on Cancer
Introduction to Real World Data
Using RWD to Support Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Strengths and Limitations of Using RWD to Support Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Internal Validity versus Generalizability
Sources for RWD generation
Using Cancer Registries
Statistical Analyses of RWD: Addressing Selection Bias
Propensity Score Modelling
Instrumental Variable Methods
Summary and Conclusion
Exercises for Chapter
9. Reporting and Interpreting Results of Cost-effectiveness Analyses from Cancer trials
Interpreting Incremental Costs and Utilities
Interpreting Incremental QALYs
Relationship between costs and QALYs
Interpreting the ICER and the Cost-effectiveness Plane
Presenting and interpreting results from uncertainty analyses
Limitations of the ICER and using the INMB
Presenting and interpreting results from Value of Information Analyses (VOI)
Exercises
10. Important Lessons from Failed Reimbursement Attempts
A List of rejected cancer drugs by NICE
When it's useded
Summary of criticisms of Economic Models of Cancer
Factors Predictive of successful HTAs in Cancer
The changing pace of the reimbursement environment
Reimbursement and payer evidence requirements across different countries
Pricing and reimbursement environment in United States
Value based pricing (VBP) for Cancer Drugs
Risk Sharing Scheme
The Future of Cost-effectiveness of Cancer Treatments
Future Research: Methodology
Future Reimbursement Landscape